The Magic Mouse is the one Apple accessory people argue about and then buy anyway. You either love the seamless glass top and its swipe-and-scroll gestures, or you have strong feelings about charging it from the bottom. What almost nobody argues about is the price: paying full Apple retail for a mouse that has barely changed in a decade is a hard case to make. A gently-used one glides, clicks and gestures exactly like a sealed one, which is precisely why the refurbished market is the sensible way to get a true Apple pointer on your desk.
The numbers that change the conversation
Top refurbished apple magic mouses on eBay right now
Here is a live snapshot of what Australian sellers are listing today, so you can weigh condition, generation and price side by side.
Listings update automatically and open in a new tab.
Why second-hand is not “second best”
Strip a Magic Mouse back to its essentials and there is remarkably little to go wrong. There is no scroll wheel to clog, no rubber side grips to perish, and no mechanical buttons in the traditional sense. The entire top is a single sheet of Multi-Touch glass that registers clicks and gestures, and the bottom carries two low-friction feet, an optical laser sensor and a sealed rechargeable cell. None of that is the kind of part that quietly degrades after a year on someone else’s desk. The sensor that tracks across your mouse mat is the same sensor whether the unit shipped last week or three years ago.
The single genuine wear item is the internal battery, and on this device it is hardly a worry. The Magic Mouse holds a charge for roughly a month of normal use, and a quick top-up restores hours of work in minutes. Even a cell that has lost a slice of its original capacity will still run for weeks between charges. The gesture surface itself is solid-state, so unlike a worn-out clicky wheel on a cheaper mouse, there is simply nothing on top to wear smooth or stop responding.
The glass surface you swipe today and the one a previous owner returned last month track, click and gesture identically. With a Magic Mouse, you are paying for the seal on the box, not for the feel under your hand.
The savings are real
Apple holds the Magic Mouse at a firm price new, and the white version with the matching Multi-Touch surface has stayed stubbornly expensive for what is, at heart, a single-button glass shell. On the used and refurbished market the same mouse routinely lands in the 20-60% cheaper bracket. The biggest discounts usually attach to the earlier Lightning-charging generation, which works exactly like the current one but charges over an older cable. If you already have a Lightning cable from a previous iPhone in a drawer, that earlier model is frequently the best-value Apple pointer you can buy in Australia. The tracking, the clicking and the gestures are unchanged; only the charging port and the price tag differ.
New vs used, side by side
| Brand new | Used / refurbished | |
|---|---|---|
| Tracking and gestures | Multi-Touch glass surface | Identical Multi-Touch glass surface |
| Price | Full Apple retail | 20-60% less |
| Battery | 100% capacity | Slightly used, still weeks per charge |
| Charging port | Current USB-C model only | USB-C or cheaper Lightning models |
| Cosmetics | Flawless glass top | Light desk wear or feet marks possible |
| Environmental cost | New manufacturing footprint | Reuses an existing device |
The five-minute checklist before you pay
- Identify the generation by its port. Turn the mouse over in the photos. A Lightning port means the older, cheaper model; a USB-C port means the current one. Both work the same, so let your existing cables guide the choice.
- Inspect the glass top closely. Ask for a clear, well-lit photo of the Multi-Touch surface. Hairline scratches are cosmetic, but a deep gouge can interfere with gesture tracking near that spot.
- Check the two feet on the underside. Worn or peeling feet make the mouse drag instead of glide. They are cheap to replace, but you want to know before you pay, not after.
- Confirm the click still feels crisp. The whole shell tilts to click. A good seller will state that both left and right clicks register cleanly with no mushiness or double-clicking.
- Verify it pairs over Bluetooth. Ask that it has been tested and connects without dropouts, and that gestures like two-finger swipe are working in System Settings.
You have more protection than you think
Buying refurbished in Australia does not mean buying blind. When you purchase from a business, an eBay store or a registered refurbisher rather than a private individual, the Australian Consumer Law still applies. The mouse must be of acceptable quality, match its description and be fit for its purpose. If a “refurbished” Magic Mouse arrives that will not hold a charge, will not pair, or has a gesture surface that ignores half your swipes, you have a clear right to a repair, replacement or refund. That consumer guarantee sits on top of any warranty the seller offers and cannot be waived, which is exactly why a reputable business seller is usually the safest place to buy.
Ready to find yours?
Browse current refurbished and used Magic Mouse deals from trusted Australian sellers below.
Red flags to walk away from
- “Charging port temperamental.” The Magic Mouse charges from the bottom, so it is briefly unusable while plugged in. A flaky port turns a one-minute top-up into a daily frustration. Walk away.
- No mention of gesture testing. A seller who confirms it powers on but says nothing about swipe and scroll is avoiding the one feature that defines this mouse.
- Cracked or chipped glass. A clean scratch is cosmetic; a crack in the Multi-Touch surface can kill gestures in that zone permanently. Insist on real close-up photos.
- “Right-click not working.” Right-click is a software-assigned gesture, not a fault, but a listing that frames it as a defect signals a seller who has not actually set the mouse up or tested it.
- Private seller, no returns, cash only. Step outside a proper business transaction and you lose your consumer-law footing entirely.
Frequently asked questions
Can I really not use the Magic Mouse while it charges? Correct, the port is on the bottom, so it sits face-down during a top-up. The upside is that a few minutes on the cable buys hours of use, and a full charge lasts about a month, so this rarely interrupts a real working day.
Does the older Lightning model still work properly in 2026? Yes. It tracks, clicks and gestures identically to the USB-C version. The only difference is the cable it charges with, and it is usually the biggest saving on the page.
Will a refurbished Magic Mouse work with my iPad? Yes. It pairs over Bluetooth with a compatible iPad just as it does with a Mac, and basic pointing and clicking work straight away. Some advanced gestures are Mac-focused, but everyday use is covered.
How do I know the glass surface is genuine, not a counterfeit? Look for the seamless one-piece glass top with no visible seams or buttons, the Apple model number etched on the underside, and real photos from the seller. A business listing with clear images makes fakes easy to spot.
The bottom line
Few Apple peripherals suit the second-hand buyer as neatly as the Magic Mouse. The gesture surface is solid-state, the sensor does not age, and the much-debated bottom port is a quirk rather than a wear point. Decide whether the cheaper Lightning generation or the current USB-C one fits your cables, check the glass, the feet and the click, and buy from a seller who stands behind it. Do that and you walk away with a genuine Apple pointer for a price that makes the boxed one look hard to justify, while keeping one more working device out of the 588,000 tonnes of e-waste Australia produces each year.
This article may contain affiliate links; see our Affiliate Disclosure.